WorkerProto: Support fine-grained protocol feature negotiation

Currently, the worker protocol has a version number that we increment
whenever we change something in the protocol. However, this can cause
a collision between Nix PRs / forks that make protocol changes
(e.g. PR #9857 increments the version, which could collide with
another PR). So instead, the client and daemon now exchange a set of
protocol features (such as `auth-forwarding`). They will use the
intersection of the sets of features, i.e. the features they both
support.

Note that protocol features are completely distinct from
`ExperimentalFeature`s.

src/libstore/daemon.cc

@@ -1025,19 +1025,20 @@ void processConnection(
 #endif
 
     /* Exchange the greeting. */
-    WorkerProto::Version clientVersion =
+    auto [protoVersion, features] =
         WorkerProto::BasicServerConnection::handshake(
-            to, from, PROTOCOL_VERSION);
+            to, from, PROTOCOL_VERSION, WorkerProto::allFeatures);
 
-    if (clientVersion < 0x10a)
+    if (protoVersion < 0x10a)
         throw Error("the Nix client version is too old");
 
     WorkerProto::BasicServerConnection conn;
     conn.to = std::move(to);
     conn.from = std::move(from);
-    conn.protoVersion = clientVersion;
+    conn.protoVersion = protoVersion;
+    conn.features = features;
 
-    auto tunnelLogger = new TunnelLogger(conn.to, clientVersion);
+    auto tunnelLogger = new TunnelLogger(conn.to, protoVersion);
     auto prevLogger = nix::logger;
     // FIXME
     if (!recursive)

src/libstore/remote-store.cc

@@ -73,8 +73,11 @@ void RemoteStore::initConnection(Connection & conn)
         StringSink saved;
         TeeSource tee(conn.from, saved);
         try {
-            conn.protoVersion = WorkerProto::BasicClientConnection::handshake(
+            auto [protoVersion, features] = WorkerProto::BasicClientConnection::handshake(
-                conn.to, tee, PROTOCOL_VERSION);
+                conn.to, tee, PROTOCOL_VERSION,
+                WorkerProto::allFeatures);
+            conn.protoVersion = protoVersion;
+            conn.features = features;
         } catch (SerialisationError & e) {
             /* In case the other side is waiting for our input, close
                it. */
@@ -88,6 +91,9 @@ void RemoteStore::initConnection(Connection & conn)
 
         static_cast<WorkerProto::ClientHandshakeInfo &>(conn) = conn.postHandshake(*this);
 
+        for (auto & feature : conn.features)
+            debug("negotiated feature '%s'", feature);
+
         auto ex = conn.processStderrReturn();
         if (ex) std::rethrow_exception(ex);
     }

src/libstore/worker-protocol-connection.cc

@@ -5,6 +5,8 @@
 
 namespace nix {
 
+const std::set<WorkerProto::Feature> WorkerProto::allFeatures{};
+
 WorkerProto::BasicClientConnection::~BasicClientConnection()
 {
     try {
@@ -137,8 +139,21 @@ void WorkerProto::BasicClientConnection::processStderr(bool * daemonException, S
     }
 }
 
-WorkerProto::Version
+static std::set<WorkerProto::Feature>
-WorkerProto::BasicClientConnection::handshake(BufferedSink & to, Source & from, WorkerProto::Version localVersion)
+intersectFeatures(const std::set<WorkerProto::Feature> & a, const std::set<WorkerProto::Feature> & b)
+{
+    std::set<WorkerProto::Feature> res;
+    for (auto & x : a)
+        if (b.contains(x))
+            res.insert(x);
+    return res;
+}
+
+std::tuple<WorkerProto::Version, std::set<WorkerProto::Feature>> WorkerProto::BasicClientConnection::handshake(
+    BufferedSink & to,
+    Source & from,
+    WorkerProto::Version localVersion,
+    const std::set<WorkerProto::Feature> & supportedFeatures)
 {
     to << WORKER_MAGIC_1 << localVersion;
     to.flush();
@@ -153,11 +168,24 @@ WorkerProto::BasicClientConnection::handshake(BufferedSink & to, Source & from,
     if (GET_PROTOCOL_MINOR(daemonVersion) < 10)
         throw Error("the Nix daemon version is too old");
 
-    return std::min(daemonVersion, localVersion);
+    auto protoVersion = std::min(daemonVersion, localVersion);
+
+    /* Exchange features. */
+    std::set<WorkerProto::Feature> daemonFeatures;
+    if (GET_PROTOCOL_MINOR(protoVersion) >= 38) {
+        to << supportedFeatures;
+        to.flush();
+        daemonFeatures = readStrings<std::set<WorkerProto::Feature>>(from);
     }
 
-WorkerProto::Version
+    return {protoVersion, intersectFeatures(daemonFeatures, supportedFeatures)};
-WorkerProto::BasicServerConnection::handshake(BufferedSink & to, Source & from, WorkerProto::Version localVersion)
+}
+
+std::tuple<WorkerProto::Version, std::set<WorkerProto::Feature>> WorkerProto::BasicServerConnection::handshake(
+    BufferedSink & to,
+    Source & from,
+    WorkerProto::Version localVersion,
+    const std::set<WorkerProto::Feature> & supportedFeatures)
 {
     unsigned int magic = readInt(from);
     if (magic != WORKER_MAGIC_1)
@@ -165,7 +193,18 @@ WorkerProto::BasicServerConnection::handshake(BufferedSink & to, Source & from,
     to << WORKER_MAGIC_2 << localVersion;
     to.flush();
     auto clientVersion = readInt(from);
-    return std::min(clientVersion, localVersion);
+
+    auto protoVersion = std::min(clientVersion, localVersion);
+
+    /* Exchange features. */
+    std::set<WorkerProto::Feature> clientFeatures;
+    if (GET_PROTOCOL_MINOR(protoVersion) >= 38) {
+        clientFeatures = readStrings<std::set<WorkerProto::Feature>>(from);
+        to << supportedFeatures;
+        to.flush();
+    }
+
+    return {protoVersion, intersectFeatures(clientFeatures, supportedFeatures)};
 }
 
 WorkerProto::ClientHandshakeInfo WorkerProto::BasicClientConnection::postHandshake(const StoreDirConfig & store)

src/libstore/worker-protocol-connection.hh

@@ -23,6 +23,11 @@ struct WorkerProto::BasicConnection
      */
     WorkerProto::Version protoVersion;
 
+    /**
+     * The set of features that both sides support.
+     */
+    std::set<Feature> features;
+
     /**
      * Coercion to `WorkerProto::ReadConn`. This makes it easy to use the
      * factored out serve protocol serializers with a
@@ -72,8 +77,8 @@ struct WorkerProto::BasicClientConnection : WorkerProto::BasicConnection
     /**
      * Establishes connection, negotiating version.
      *
-     * @return the version provided by the other side of the
+     * @return the minimum version supported by both sides and the set
-     * connection.
+     * of protocol features supported by both sides.
      *
      * @param to Taken by reference to allow for various error handling
      * mechanisms.
@@ -82,8 +87,15 @@ struct WorkerProto::BasicClientConnection : WorkerProto::BasicConnection
      * handling mechanisms.
      *
      * @param localVersion Our version which is sent over
+     *
+     * @param features The protocol features that we support
      */
-    static Version handshake(BufferedSink & to, Source & from, WorkerProto::Version localVersion);
+    // FIXME: this should probably be a constructor.
+    static std::tuple<Version, std::set<Feature>> handshake(
+        BufferedSink & to,
+        Source & from,
+        WorkerProto::Version localVersion,
+        const std::set<Feature> & supportedFeatures);
 
     /**
      * After calling handshake, must call this to exchange some basic
@@ -138,8 +150,15 @@ struct WorkerProto::BasicServerConnection : WorkerProto::BasicConnection
      * handling mechanisms.
      *
      * @param localVersion Our version which is sent over
+     *
+     * @param features The protocol features that we support
      */
-    static WorkerProto::Version handshake(BufferedSink & to, Source & from, WorkerProto::Version localVersion);
+    // FIXME: this should probably be a constructor.
+    static std::tuple<Version, std::set<Feature>> handshake(
+        BufferedSink & to,
+        Source & from,
+        WorkerProto::Version localVersion,
+        const std::set<Feature> & supportedFeatures);
 
     /**
      * After calling handshake, must call this to exchange some basic

src/libstore/worker-protocol.hh

@@ -11,7 +11,9 @@ namespace nix {
 #define WORKER_MAGIC_1 0x6e697863
 #define WORKER_MAGIC_2 0x6478696f
 
-#define PROTOCOL_VERSION (1 << 8 | 37)
+/* Note: you generally shouldn't change the protocol version. Define a
+   new `WorkerProto::Feature` instead. */
+#define PROTOCOL_VERSION (1 << 8 | 38)
 #define GET_PROTOCOL_MAJOR(x) ((x) & 0xff00)
 #define GET_PROTOCOL_MINOR(x) ((x) & 0x00ff)
 
@@ -131,6 +133,10 @@ struct WorkerProto
     {
         WorkerProto::Serialise<T>::write(store, conn, t);
     }
+
+    using Feature = std::string;
+
+    static const std::set<Feature> allFeatures;
 };
 
 enum struct WorkerProto::Op : uint64_t

tests/unit/libstore/worker-protocol.cc

@@ -658,15 +658,15 @@ TEST_F(WorkerProtoTest, handshake_log)
             FdSink out { toServer.writeSide.get() };
             FdSource in0 { toClient.readSide.get() };
             TeeSource in { in0, toClientLog };
-            clientResult = WorkerProto::BasicClientConnection::handshake(
+            clientResult = std::get<0>(WorkerProto::BasicClientConnection::handshake(
-                out, in, defaultVersion);
+                    out, in, defaultVersion, {}));
         });
 
         {
             FdSink out { toClient.writeSide.get() };
             FdSource in { toServer.readSide.get() };
             WorkerProto::BasicServerConnection::handshake(
-                out, in, defaultVersion);
+                out, in, defaultVersion, {});
         };
 
         thread.join();
@@ -675,6 +675,33 @@ TEST_F(WorkerProtoTest, handshake_log)
     });
 }
 
+TEST_F(WorkerProtoTest, handshake_features)
+{
+    Pipe toClient, toServer;
+    toClient.create();
+    toServer.create();
+
+    std::tuple<WorkerProto::Version, std::set<WorkerProto::Feature>> clientResult;
+
+    auto clientThread = std::thread([&]() {
+        FdSink out { toServer.writeSide.get() };
+        FdSource in { toClient.readSide.get() };
+        clientResult = WorkerProto::BasicClientConnection::handshake(
+            out, in, 123, {"bar", "aap", "mies", "xyzzy"});
+    });
+
+    FdSink out { toClient.writeSide.get() };
+    FdSource in { toServer.readSide.get() };
+    auto daemonResult = WorkerProto::BasicServerConnection::handshake(
+        out, in, 456, {"foo", "bar", "xyzzy"});
+
+    clientThread.join();
+
+    EXPECT_EQ(clientResult, daemonResult);
+    EXPECT_EQ(std::get<0>(clientResult), 123);
+    EXPECT_EQ(std::get<1>(clientResult), std::set<WorkerProto::Feature>({"bar", "xyzzy"}));
+}
+
 /// Has to be a `BufferedSink` for handshake.
 struct NullBufferedSink : BufferedSink {
     void writeUnbuffered(std::string_view data) override { }
@@ -686,8 +713,8 @@ TEST_F(WorkerProtoTest, handshake_client_replay)
         NullBufferedSink nullSink;
 
         StringSource in { toClientLog };
-        auto clientResult = WorkerProto::BasicClientConnection::handshake(
+        auto clientResult = std::get<0>(WorkerProto::BasicClientConnection::handshake(
-            nullSink, in, defaultVersion);
+                nullSink, in, defaultVersion, {}));
 
         EXPECT_EQ(clientResult, defaultVersion);
     });
@@ -705,13 +732,13 @@ TEST_F(WorkerProtoTest, handshake_client_truncated_replay_throws)
             if (len < 8) {
                 EXPECT_THROW(
                     WorkerProto::BasicClientConnection::handshake(
-                        nullSink, in, defaultVersion),
+                        nullSink, in, defaultVersion, {}),
                     EndOfFile);
             } else {
                 // Not sure why cannot keep on checking for `EndOfFile`.
                 EXPECT_THROW(
                     WorkerProto::BasicClientConnection::handshake(
-                        nullSink, in, defaultVersion),
+                        nullSink, in, defaultVersion, {}),
                     Error);
             }
         }
@@ -734,17 +761,17 @@ TEST_F(WorkerProtoTest, handshake_client_corrupted_throws)
                 // magic bytes don't match
                 EXPECT_THROW(
                     WorkerProto::BasicClientConnection::handshake(
-                        nullSink, in, defaultVersion),
+                        nullSink, in, defaultVersion, {}),
                     Error);
             } else if (idx < 8 || idx >= 12) {
                 // Number out of bounds
                 EXPECT_THROW(
                     WorkerProto::BasicClientConnection::handshake(
-                        nullSink, in, defaultVersion),
+                        nullSink, in, defaultVersion, {}),
                     SerialisationError);
             } else {
-                auto ver = WorkerProto::BasicClientConnection::handshake(
+                auto ver = std::get<0>(WorkerProto::BasicClientConnection::handshake(
-                    nullSink, in, defaultVersion);
+                        nullSink, in, defaultVersion, {}));
                 // `std::min` of this and the other version saves us
                 EXPECT_EQ(ver, defaultVersion);
             }