Improve the error message for “multicommands” commands (#9510)

* Factor out the default `MultiCommand` behavior

All the `MultiCommand`s had (nearly) the same behavior when called
without a subcommand.
Factor out this behavior into the `NixMultiCommand` class.

* Display the list of available subcommands when none is specified

Whenever a user runs a command that excepts a subcommand, add the list
of available subcommands to the error message.

* Print the multi-command lists as Markdown lists

This takes more screen real estate, but is also much more readable than
a comma-separated list

src/libcmd/command.cc

@@ -1,4 +1,5 @@
 #include "command.hh"
+#include "markdown.hh"
 #include "store-api.hh"
 #include "local-fs-store.hh"
 #include "derivations.hh"
@@ -34,6 +35,19 @@ nlohmann::json NixMultiCommand::toJSON()
     return MultiCommand::toJSON();
 }
 
+void NixMultiCommand::run()
+{
+    if (!command) {
+        std::set<std::string> subCommandTextLines;
+        for (auto & [name, _] : commands)
+            subCommandTextLines.insert(fmt("- `%s`", name));
+        std::string markdownError = fmt("`nix %s` requires a sub-command. Available sub-commands:\n\n%s\n",
+                commandName, concatStringsSep("\n", subCommandTextLines));
+        throw UsageError(renderMarkdownToTerminal(markdownError));
+    }
+    command->second->run();
+}
+
 StoreCommand::StoreCommand()
 {
 }

src/libcmd/command.hh

@@ -26,9 +26,13 @@ static constexpr Command::Category catNixInstallation = 102;
 
 static constexpr auto installablesCategory = "Options that change the interpretation of [installables](@docroot@/command-ref/new-cli/nix.md#installables)";
 
-struct NixMultiCommand : virtual MultiCommand, virtual Command
+struct NixMultiCommand : MultiCommand, virtual Command
 {
     nlohmann::json toJSON() override;
+
+    using MultiCommand::MultiCommand;
+
+    virtual void run() override;
 };
 
 // For the overloaded run methods

src/libutil/args.cc

@@ -622,8 +622,9 @@ std::optional<ExperimentalFeature> Command::experimentalFeature ()
     return { Xp::NixCommand };
 }
 
-MultiCommand::MultiCommand(const Commands & commands_)
+MultiCommand::MultiCommand(std::string_view commandName, const Commands & commands_)
     : commands(commands_)
+    , commandName(commandName)
 {
     expectArgs({
         .label = "subcommand",

src/libutil/args.hh

@@ -356,13 +356,16 @@ public:
      */
     std::optional<std::pair<std::string, ref<Command>>> command;
 
-    MultiCommand(const Commands & commands);
+    MultiCommand(std::string_view commandName, const Commands & commands);
 
     bool processFlag(Strings::iterator & pos, Strings::iterator end) override;
 
     bool processArgs(const Strings & args, bool finish) override;
 
     nlohmann::json toJSON() override;
+
+protected:
+    std::string commandName = "";
 };
 
 Strings argvToStrings(int argc, char * * argv);

src/nix/config.cc

@@ -7,9 +7,9 @@
 
 using namespace nix;
 
-struct CmdConfig : virtual NixMultiCommand
+struct CmdConfig : NixMultiCommand
 {
-    CmdConfig() : MultiCommand(RegisterCommand::getCommandsFor({"config"}))
+    CmdConfig() : NixMultiCommand("config", RegisterCommand::getCommandsFor({"config"}))
     { }
 
     std::string description() override
@@ -18,13 +18,6 @@ struct CmdConfig : virtual NixMultiCommand
     }
 
     Category category() override { return catUtility; }
-
-    void run() override
-    {
-        if (!command)
-            throw UsageError("'nix config' requires a sub-command.");
-        command->second->run();
-    }
 };
 
 struct CmdConfigShow : Command, MixJSON

src/nix/derivation.cc

@@ -2,9 +2,9 @@
 
 using namespace nix;
 
-struct CmdDerivation : virtual NixMultiCommand
+struct CmdDerivation : NixMultiCommand
 {
-    CmdDerivation() : MultiCommand(RegisterCommand::getCommandsFor({"derivation"}))
+    CmdDerivation() : NixMultiCommand("derivation", RegisterCommand::getCommandsFor({"derivation"}))
     { }
 
     std::string description() override
@@ -13,13 +13,6 @@ struct CmdDerivation : virtual NixMultiCommand
     }
 
     Category category() override { return catUtility; }
-
-    void run() override
-    {
-        if (!command)
-            throw UsageError("'nix derivation' requires a sub-command.");
-        command->second->run();
-    }
 };
 
 static auto rCmdDerivation = registerCommand<CmdDerivation>("derivation");

src/nix/flake.cc

@@ -1399,7 +1399,9 @@ struct CmdFlakePrefetch : FlakeCommand, MixJSON
 struct CmdFlake : NixMultiCommand
 {
     CmdFlake()
-        : MultiCommand({
+        : NixMultiCommand(
+            "flake",
+            {
                 {"update", []() { return make_ref<CmdFlakeUpdate>(); }},
                 {"lock", []() { return make_ref<CmdFlakeLock>(); }},
                 {"metadata", []() { return make_ref<CmdFlakeMetadata>(); }},
@@ -1429,10 +1431,8 @@ struct CmdFlake : NixMultiCommand
 
     void run() override
     {
-        if (!command)
-            throw UsageError("'nix flake' requires a sub-command.");
         experimentalFeatureSettings.require(Xp::Flakes);
-        command->second->run();
+        NixMultiCommand::run();
     }
 };
 

src/nix/hash.cc

@@ -130,7 +130,9 @@ struct CmdToBase : Command
 struct CmdHash : NixMultiCommand
 {
     CmdHash()
-        : MultiCommand({
+        : NixMultiCommand(
+            "hash",
+            {
                 {"file", []() { return make_ref<CmdHashBase>(FileIngestionMethod::Flat);; }},
                 {"path", []() { return make_ref<CmdHashBase>(FileIngestionMethod::Recursive); }},
                 {"to-base16", []() { return make_ref<CmdToBase>(HashFormat::Base16); }},
@@ -146,13 +148,6 @@ struct CmdHash : NixMultiCommand
     }
 
     Category category() override { return catUtility; }
-
-    void run() override
-    {
-        if (!command)
-            throw UsageError("'nix hash' requires a sub-command.");
-        command->second->run();
-    }
 };
 
 static auto rCmdHash = registerCommand<CmdHash>("hash");

src/nix/main.cc

@@ -67,7 +67,7 @@ struct NixArgs : virtual MultiCommand, virtual MixCommonArgs, virtual RootArgs
     bool helpRequested = false;
     bool showVersion = false;
 
-    NixArgs() : MultiCommand(RegisterCommand::getCommandsFor({})), MixCommonArgs("nix")
+    NixArgs() : MultiCommand("", RegisterCommand::getCommandsFor({})), MixCommonArgs("nix")
     {
         categories.clear();
         categories[catHelp] = "Help commands";

src/nix/nar.cc

@@ -4,7 +4,7 @@ using namespace nix;
 
 struct CmdNar : NixMultiCommand
 {
-    CmdNar() : MultiCommand(RegisterCommand::getCommandsFor({"nar"}))
+    CmdNar() : NixMultiCommand("nar", RegisterCommand::getCommandsFor({"nar"}))
     { }
 
     std::string description() override
@@ -20,13 +20,6 @@ struct CmdNar : NixMultiCommand
     }
 
     Category category() override { return catUtility; }
-
-    void run() override
-    {
-        if (!command)
-            throw UsageError("'nix nar' requires a sub-command.");
-        command->second->run();
-    }
 };
 
 static auto rCmdNar = registerCommand<CmdNar>("nar");

src/nix/profile.cc

@@ -825,7 +825,9 @@ struct CmdProfileWipeHistory : virtual StoreCommand, MixDefaultProfile, MixDryRu
 struct CmdProfile : NixMultiCommand
 {
     CmdProfile()
-        : MultiCommand({
+        : NixMultiCommand(
+            "profile",
+            {
               {"install", []() { return make_ref<CmdProfileInstall>(); }},
               {"remove", []() { return make_ref<CmdProfileRemove>(); }},
               {"upgrade", []() { return make_ref<CmdProfileUpgrade>(); }},
@@ -848,13 +850,6 @@ struct CmdProfile : NixMultiCommand
           #include "profile.md"
           ;
     }
-
-    void run() override
-    {
-        if (!command)
-            throw UsageError("'nix profile' requires a sub-command.");
-        command->second->run();
-    }
 };
 
 static auto rCmdProfile = registerCommand<CmdProfile>("profile");

src/nix/realisation.cc

@@ -5,9 +5,9 @@
 
 using namespace nix;
 
-struct CmdRealisation : virtual NixMultiCommand
+struct CmdRealisation : NixMultiCommand
 {
-    CmdRealisation() : MultiCommand(RegisterCommand::getCommandsFor({"realisation"}))
+    CmdRealisation() : NixMultiCommand("realisation", RegisterCommand::getCommandsFor({"realisation"}))
     { }
 
     std::string description() override
@@ -16,13 +16,6 @@ struct CmdRealisation : virtual NixMultiCommand
     }
 
     Category category() override { return catUtility; }
-
-    void run() override
-    {
-        if (!command)
-            throw UsageError("'nix realisation' requires a sub-command.");
-        command->second->run();
-    }
 };
 
 static auto rCmdRealisation = registerCommand<CmdRealisation>("realisation");

src/nix/registry.cc

@@ -196,10 +196,12 @@ struct CmdRegistryPin : RegistryCommand, EvalCommand
     }
 };
 
-struct CmdRegistry : virtual NixMultiCommand
+struct CmdRegistry : NixMultiCommand
 {
     CmdRegistry()
-        : MultiCommand({
+        : NixMultiCommand(
+            "registry",
+            {
                 {"list", []() { return make_ref<CmdRegistryList>(); }},
                 {"add", []() { return make_ref<CmdRegistryAdd>(); }},
                 {"remove", []() { return make_ref<CmdRegistryRemove>(); }},
@@ -221,14 +223,6 @@ struct CmdRegistry : virtual NixMultiCommand
     }
 
     Category category() override { return catSecondary; }
-
-    void run() override
-    {
-        experimentalFeatureSettings.require(Xp::Flakes);
-        if (!command)
-            throw UsageError("'nix registry' requires a sub-command.");
-        command->second->run();
-    }
 };
 
 static auto rCmdRegistry = registerCommand<CmdRegistry>("registry");

src/nix/sigs.cc

@@ -205,7 +205,9 @@ struct CmdKeyConvertSecretToPublic : Command
 struct CmdKey : NixMultiCommand
 {
     CmdKey()
-        : MultiCommand({
+        : NixMultiCommand(
+            "key",
+            {
                 {"generate-secret", []() { return make_ref<CmdKeyGenerateSecret>(); }},
                 {"convert-secret-to-public", []() { return make_ref<CmdKeyConvertSecretToPublic>(); }},
             })
@@ -218,13 +220,6 @@ struct CmdKey : NixMultiCommand
     }
 
     Category category() override { return catUtility; }
-
-    void run() override
-    {
-        if (!command)
-            throw UsageError("'nix key' requires a sub-command.");
-        command->second->run();
-    }
 };
 
 static auto rCmdKey = registerCommand<CmdKey>("key");

src/nix/store.cc

@@ -2,9 +2,9 @@
 
 using namespace nix;
 
-struct CmdStore : virtual NixMultiCommand
+struct CmdStore : NixMultiCommand
 {
-    CmdStore() : MultiCommand(RegisterCommand::getCommandsFor({"store"}))
+    CmdStore() : NixMultiCommand("store", RegisterCommand::getCommandsFor({"store"}))
     { }
 
     std::string description() override
@@ -13,13 +13,6 @@ struct CmdStore : virtual NixMultiCommand
     }
 
     Category category() override { return catUtility; }
-
-    void run() override
-    {
-        if (!command)
-            throw UsageError("'nix store' requires a sub-command.");
-        command->second->run();
-    }
 };
 
 static auto rCmdStore = registerCommand<CmdStore>("store");